It is natural to sort plans by monthly price and pick the top one. But the premium is only what you pay to keep the plan. What you pay when you actually use it is a separate number, and it can be much larger.
Four numbers, not one
- Premium: what you pay every month, whether or not you see a doctor.
- Deductible: what you pay for covered care before the plan starts paying its share.
- Copays and coinsurance: your share of each visit, test or prescription.
- Out-of-pocket maximum: the most you would pay for covered, in-network care in a year. After that, the plan pays 100%.
How the trade-off works
On HealthCare.gov's own chart, a Bronze plan pays about 60% of an average person's costs and a Gold plan about 80%. Bronze plans usually have the lower monthly premium and a high deductible; Gold plans usually cost more each month and have a low deductible (source).
So the question is not "which is less per month?" but "which costs me less over the year, for the care I expect to use?"
A simple way to compare
- Add up 12 months of premium for each plan.
- Estimate your care for the year: regular visits, prescriptions, any planned surgery or therapy.
- Work out what each plan would charge you for that care, given its deductible and copays.
- Add the two together. Then look at the out-of-pocket maximum as your worst case.
Someone who rarely sees a doctor may come out ahead with a lower premium. Someone with ongoing prescriptions, a chronic condition or a baby on the way often comes out ahead with a higher premium and a lower deductible. HealthCare.gov walks through total costs the same way.
Check the network too
A plan with a low price and a narrow network can still cost more if your doctors aren't in it. Before you choose, confirm your doctors and hospitals are in the plan's network.
Sources: HealthCare.gov: premium · deductible · copayment · coinsurance · out-of-pocket maximum · plan categories · total costs · network